By Will Barber – Taylor
“Happiness will prevail”
The Doctor has heard rumours about Terra Alpha. People are going missing. Happiness Patrols are walking the streets and arresting anyone who is not happy. He decides to take Ace there to stop the tyrannical rule of Helen A who is murdering thousands of people who are not happy. With the help of Earl Sigma and a former member of the Happiness Patrol, The Doctor goes about starting a revolution.
“The Happiness Patrol” is a very political story. From allusions of the EU to a leader who very much resembles the much hated dictator, Margaret Thatcher. Okay, so the last bit was a tad over the top but The Happiness Patrol’s not exactly subtle political message is very clear. Well, obviously not to everyone given that it took Newsnight and some members of the general public (including certain members of the press) about twenty years to realise this. However, the writer and the entire cast knew what it was meant to be which performance and production wise is all that mattered.
Shelia Hancock’s performance as Helen A is wonderful. From the very first time we see her you can tell she is the villain of the piece. But is that what she really is? By the end of the final episode she is a crying mess, due to her husband leaving her and her “dog” dying. Is this truly a Tyrant? In the hit TV series, Cracker, the main character a psychologist called Fitz, remarks of a killer:
“Sentimentality. I’ve seen it in every killer I’ve ever met – sickening sentimentality.”
Is this the same with Doctor Who villains? Mostly we get “monsters” rather than villains, as such. Daleks, Cybermen, Weeping Angels, the Silence. None of these monsters will ever have character development because in essence they are “cheap thrills”. Helen A, on the other hand, belongs to category two: Villains. Like Sharaz Jek in “The Caves of Androzani” or Davros in “Genesis of The Daleks”, the character is not driven by simply wanting to kill people like the above monsters, but by more human feelings.
In Genesis, Davros wants to save his people; in Caves, Sharaz Jek wants revenge and in The Happiness Patrol, Helen A wants to make her people happy, (though it has to be said she goes about it in the weirdest most sc-fi/ Hammer Horror way.) these are all real human emotions. Indeed, the true villain of the piece from Helen A’s eyes is The Doctor. This truly demonstrates how perspective can be truly subjective. By the end we do feel for Helen A, but we don’t have sympathy for her. She has caused untold horror to millions of people over her reign and yet, in a way, we understand why she did it. Now that is a true monster. If you can understand the reason somebody did such a terrible thing, then that means that what they did was human in a twisted way. As the Master said in “Last of The Timelords” “The human race. The biggest monsters of them all.”
Sadly one of the aspects of “The Happiness Patrol” which lets it down is the effects. From Fo-fo (Helen A’s pet) to the shot of Gilbert and Trevor C leaving the planet together, the effects are almost cringe worthy. This is not down to the fact that the story was made over 30 years ago, seeing as Caves was made several years earlier yet has much better effects. Indeed, the effects are the only thing that lets the story down.
“The Happiness Patrol” is an odd story. It lingers between the past and the present, having a “monster” that looks like it comes from the 60s (aka The Candy Man) yet having a main villain New Who would be proud to have. In fact, “The Happiness Patrol” truly is an example of 80s Who, a mixture between the modern and the new, it also shows the beginning of the end of Classic Who.
- Happiness Will Prevail: ‘Doctor Who: The Happiness Patrol’ (Review) (popmatters.com)
- You Can’t Handle Doctor Who’s In-Your-Face Politics! [Video] (io9.com)
- DOCTOR WHO: A Companion’s Companion – Season 25 (nerdist.com)
- Doctor Who: The Happiness Patrol (Review) (them0vieblog.com)
- Our Doctor Countdown 11 : Sylvester McCoy (believeingeek.wordpress.com)
- The alien “Thatcher’s” devilish plotting (kattankudi.info)
- Doctor Who 50th Anniversary The Dawn of the Time War (lezgetreal.com)
- Doctor Who: The Beast Below (Review) (them0vieblog.com)
- Doctor Who: The Curse of Fenric – Special Edition (Review) (them0vieblog.com)
- TV Club: Doctor Who: “Dalek” (avclub.com)